| Turning On The Sun
A consumer guide to solar water
heating
|
Domestic Hot Water Systems
The principles involved in heating household water with the sun are not
complex or new. However, state-of-the-art solar-heating equipment must be
designed, installed and used properly to effect dollar and energy savings for
the consumer.
The chief component of any solar water heating system is the collector. Solar
collectors absorb the radiant energy of the sun and change it into heat energy.
The flat-plate collector is the predominant type used in solar domestic
hot water (DHW) systems.
A typical flat-plate collector consists of a rectangular surface (absorber)
with a series of fluid tubes running lengthwise along it. Liquid (in Florida,
usually water) from the storage tank flows through the tubes. The absorber is
usually composed of a good conductible material, such as copper or aluminum, and
is coated black to absorb as much sunlight as possible. As the plate is heated,
by exposure to sunlight, it transfers the heat to the liquid in the tubes.
A second type of collector is the Integral Collector Storage (ICS)
unit. The outstanding feature of this collector is that collection and storage
are in the same unit. ICS units are very similar to standard flat plate
collectors, though they contain either very large storage tubes or small tanks.
The bottom and sides of the absorber are insulated to minimize heat loss. In
addition, a translucent glass or plastic cover placed above it allows sunlight
to strike the absorber while reducing the amount of heat that can escape.
In most systems, the collector is mounted on the roof of the dwelling,
oriented to the south or within 45 degrees east or west of due south, and tilted
between 20 and 40 degrees to horizontal. Systems may be ground-mounted with the
same orientation and tilt as roof-mounted systems.
When collectors are mounted on sloping roofs, they should be mounted parallel
to the roof because of structural and aesthetic considerations. If the natural
roof slope does not correspond to the optimum collector tilt, the collector
still should be mounted parallel to the roof. The collector area may be
increased if necessary.
The storage tank is the second major component in the solar DHW system. A
conventional electric tank modified for solar service may be used, although
specially designed, sized and super-insulated solar tanks are available.
In a pumped system, cold water is drawn from the bottom of the tank,
circulated through copper piping to the rooftop collector, heated in the
collectors, then returned to the top of the storage tank. In a thermosiphon
system, pumps and controls are not necessary. Here, the tank is elevated above
the collector; as the water is heated, it rises naturally and is returned to the
top of the tank.
Similarly, ICS systems also do not require pumps or controls. On household
water draws, hot water from the collector flows to a standard hot water tank
where it replaces the water drawn. This system serves primarily as a
cost-effective preheater to the conventional water tank.
The storage tank should be large enough to provide one day's hot water
demand--i.e., 20 gallons per day per adult and 15 gallons per day per child.
Standard tank sizes available are 40, 52, 82, 100, and 120 gallons. When
converting from electric water heating to solar, an additional tank may be added
to provide the needed capacity, or the conventional tank may be replaced with a
solar-designed tank. Solar tanks are constructed with more insulation and piping
connections than conventional tanks.
Backup heating can assist during extended cloudy weather and periods of
excessive hot-water consumption. In converted electric water heaters, this is
accomplished by leaving the upper element connected (the lower element must be
disconnected) and setting the thermostat at 120 degrees F. If your home is
equipped with a dishwasher (without an automatic water heater feature), a
setting of at least 130 degrees F is recommended. Tanks designed specially for
solar are equipped with a single electric element in the upper portion of the
tank. In both electric and solar tanks it is desirable to leave the electric
current to the element turned off as much as possible to maximize the solar
contribution. A special switch may be installed in a convenient place for this
purpose.
As a rule of thumb for Florida, the storage tank size (in gallons) should be
between 1.5 and 2.5 times the size of the collector area. For example, a family
of four using an average of 80 gallons of hot water a day would need an
82-gallon tank with between 32 and 54 square feet of collector area. However,
individual calculations specific to the area and collector model are preferable.
Several sizing procedures are available to the consumer and the installer.
Generally, a solar system will provide a range of 75 to 90 percent of a
household's hot water needs, taking into consideration cloudy weather and
periods of excessive hot-water consumption.
Systems that use pumps and controls to circulate the water usually have these
two components mounted near or on the storage tank. The pump is a small
circulating type made of bronze, brass or stainless steel. The controller--which
regulates when and how long, and in some cases, how fast the pump operates--is
usually a solid-state electronic device. It senses when the collector is able to
heat the water in the tank and turns the pump on. When the water in the tank
approaches the collector temperature (within 3 to 5 degrees F), the controller
turns the pump off.
Other devices are available to control the flow of water between the tank and
collector. Timers are used to operate the pump in some systems, but you must
exercise vigilance during unfavorable weather. A snap-switch control also is
available. This device activates the pump when the collector heats to a
specified temperature. The hot water in the collector is then returned to the
tank, and cooler water is fed to the device. Sunlight striking the PV panel is
converted to electricity, which powers the pump.
The controller also may be designed to provide freeze protection by turning
the pump on to run warmed water through the collector when its temperature falls
near freezing. This type of freeze protection results in a loss of hot water and
will not work in the case of power failure, which often accompanies freezing
conditions. Other methods of freeze protection include manual and automatic
draining of the collector, a freeze prevention valve, or they use a close-looped
rather than an open-looped system. A freeze prevention valve is installed near
the collector. Whenever temperatures approach freezing, the valve opens to let
warm water flow through the collector, thereby preventing water freezing in the
collector pipes. Freeze protection is an essential feature to any solar system,
even in the usually warm Florida climate.
In an indirect system, an antifreeze solution circulated through the
collector, and a heat exchanger transfers the heat from the antifreeze solution
to the tank water. The heat exchanger prevents the antifreeze solution from
coming into contact with the potable water. In this manner, there is never any
water in the collector--only antifreeze solution. This system is common in
climates where freezing weather occurs frequently.
Drainback systems also are frequently used in areas susceptible to
freezes. In these systems, water in the collector and exposed piping drains into
an insulated reservoir tank each time the pump shuts off. During freeze
conditions, there is no water in the collector or collector piping.
Comparison Shopping
Purchase of a solar energy system is a major consumer decision. Comparison
shopping is essential and will pay off in the long run. There are many solar
equipment manufacturers and distributors in Florida; consequently, your
selection of systems and installers may be larger than you thought.
Prior to contacting a solar equipment supplier or installer you should be
familiar with the various types of solar equipment described in this booklet. If
you'd like additional information on solar equipment you can contact the Florida
Solar Energy Industries Association at 1-800-426-5899 or the FSEC Public
Information Office.
You do not need to be a technical expert to purchase solar equipment. It is
more important for you to deal with a reputable company in your area that has
the appropriate license(s). Most areas require a permit from the building
department to install a solar system.
In addition to solar contractors, plumbers, mechanical contractors, some HVAC
contractors and others may be licensed to install solar equipment in your area.
If you have any questions about permitting or licensingin your area, contact
your local building department.
It is recommended that you also contact the local consumer protection office
and the Better Business Bureau to check on the contractor that you plan to do
business with.
To select contractors in your area you can consult the Yellow Pages or you
can call the Solar Hotline at 1-800-59-SOLAR for a list of licensed contractors
in your area who have successfully completed the installation and service
training workshop offered by FlaSEIA.
In addition to price considerations you should ask to see the FSEC collector
and systems certifications for the solar equipment that you are considering.
Florida law requires that all solar systems be approved by FSEC. This requires
testing and certification of the collector and submittal of system diagrams,
homeowner manuals, and a list of system components to be approved. For a list of
approved systems contact the FSEC Public Information Office.
Thermal Performance Ratings: Current collector ratings for pool and
DHW applications are published by the FSEC Public Information Office on a
quarterly basis. While a collector is rated at three different operating
temperatures, the list provides the rating appropriate for the particular
application. Therefore, the pool collector list provides low temperature ratings
and the DHW collector list provides intermediate temperature ratings.
The rating is presented in two forms: total output, or Btu/day; and output
per square foot, or Btu/square foot x day. To approximately compare the thermal
efficiency among various collectors, use the Btu/square foot x day figure. The
higher this number is, the better the thermal design of the collector, which
means it will require fewer square feet of collector area to heat the water.
To determine the amount of energy delivered per dollar of investment, use the
Btu/day figure. Divide this figure by the total cost of the installed system.
Multiply the result by the number of collector panels or piping modules used.
This comparison can be made you receive several estimates from different
vendors.
FSEC Certification Label: Collector manufacturers and their licensees
are required to affix a label to each collector indicating FSEC certification.
This label presents much of the same data as the summary information sheet. The
consumer can verify that the collector installed is the same as the one sold by
comparing the label and summary information sheet data. The building inspector
also can use the label to verify that the collector has been certified and is
the model specified on the permit application supporting documents.
Summary Information Sheet: Each FSEC-certified collector is issued a
Summary Information Sheet which contains detailed data on the collector such as
model number, construction materials, size, test results and rating. The rating
is presented in both Btu/day and kilojoules (kj) per day. The kilojoules figure
can be used to measure electricity savings. Divide the kj/day figure by 3,600 to
find the daily energy savings in kilowatt hours (kWh). That figure can then be
multiplied by the current price of electricity (cents/kWh) to find the
approximate daily money savings. The Summary Information Sheet may be available
from the vendor or from the FSEC Testing Office.
FSEC Approved Solar Energy System Sheet: All solar energy systems sold
or manufactured in Florida must be approved by FSEC. Each system is issued an
approval sheet indicating the various components that make-up the complete
system. A schematic of the system as installed also is provided. This sheet
again may be used as verification by the consumer and the building inspector
that the equipment installed matches specifications, and, in fact, has been
approved as required by law. The system Approval Sheet may be available from the
vendor or the FSEC Testing Office.
FSEC Approved Solar Energy Systems List: This list provides a quick
reference to approved systems for the consumer and building official. Systems
are listed by company, model number and date of approval. The list is published
on a quarterly basis.
Warranties And Insurance
As with any consumer product, the warranty for your solar energy system
should be your assurance that the manufacturer and installer stand behind the
system. The terms of the warranty indicate how strongly they will stand behind
it. State and federal warranty laws have been designed to protect you.
Federal warranty law stipulates requirements where a written warranty is made
available on a product. It defines a written warranty as an affirmation of fact
or a written promise for a specified period of time. For example, if your sales
contract contains a clause that guarantees installation and materials for a
year, you have a written warranty. This triggers the requirements of the federal
law. The law does not require that a written warranty be offered. If you receive
nothing in writing, the product is covered by an implied warranty.
Written warranties are differentiated in the federal law as either full or
limited, and the appropriate designation must appear on the warranty document.
The full warranty provides for the following:
-A defective product will be fixed (or replaced) free, including removal
and reinstallation if necessary. -The product will be fixed within a
reasonable time after you complain. -You will not have to do anything
unreasonable to get warranty service (such as shipping the collector back to
the factory). -The warranty is good for anyone who owns the product during
the warranty period. -If the product can't be fixed (or hasn't been after
a reasonable effort to do so), you get your choice of a new product or a
refund. A full warranty does not necessarily cover the entire product. This
is a crucial point in the solar system purchase, since the four major components
are subject to warranty. A product can carry more then one written warranty and
may have a full warranty on one component and a limited warranty on the others.
Be sure you understand which part each warranty covers and who (manufacturer,
dealer, installer) is responsible for the warranty.
The limited warranty provides less protection than the full warranty. For
example, a limited warranty may:
-Cover only parts, not labor. -Allow only a pro-rata refund on credit.
-Require you to return a heavy product to the store for service.
-Cover only the first purchaser. -Charge for handling. Regardless of
how the warranty is labeled and how the provisions read, you still should be
cautious. Find out how long the vendor has been doing business and how he or she
plans to back up the warranty. Beware of inflated warranties that promise
everything forever.
The implied warranty is imposed by law automatically upon the sale of a
consumer product. First, the product you buy must be fit for its ordinary
purpose; for example, a solar water heater must heat your water. Second, if you
buy a product relying on the seller's advice that it can be used for a special
purpose, then this advice may create a warranty. However, all implied warranties
may be avoided by the seller if he states that no warranty is given, or that you
buy it "as is." This is unacceptable in a solar transaction.
Certain system defects or disrepair discovered during the warranty period may
not always be covered by a warranty. For example, if a component fails because
of faulty installation rather than a product defect, the manufacturer of the
product may not be required to repair the component under the warranty. For this
reason it is often critical to secure warranty coverage from the installer for
the entire system, including design and miscellaneous parts. A desirable period
for such warranty coverage is one year from the date of installation.
Another potential gap in warranty coverage falls in the area of freeze
damage. Exposure to freezing temperatures can cause a solar collector to sustain
serious damage in the absence of adequate freeze protection. Where freeze
protection is provided, and fails, the consumer may be left with a damaged
collector and no recourse under any product warranty. The typical collector
warranty contains a disclaimer which effectively relieves the manufacturer of
any obligation to repair or replace a freeze-damaged collector. The typical
freeze protection device contains a disclaimer limiting coverage of "incidental
damages." Failure of the device will obligate the manufacturer to repair or
replace it, but will not require him or her to repair or replace the collector
that froze as a result. Experience has shown that recourse to your homeowner's
insurance is the most expeditious and least costly method to cover repair or
damage caused by freezing conditions.
According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD),
insurance companies have indicated they foresee no difficulty in providing
coverage to homeowners with well-engineered and soundly constructed solar energy
systems. The system may be underwritten in the standard homeowner's policy.
The Sales Contract
Prior to making a final purchase decision, you should obtain written
estimates from various companies selected for comparison. Most companies will
provide an estimate free of charge. The written contract proposal will make
comparison shopping much easier. It should contain a description of the system
and components, including make and model number (and size where appropriate).
Total system cost including all materials and labor must be provided. It is
advisable to include a clause deferring full payment until your system is
installed and operational.
Other provisions that may be included in the contract are warranty
coverages--especially any installation warranty--and details regarding
responsibility for procurement of and payment for necessary building permits.
Once the proposal is accepted and signed by both parties, it becomes a
binding contract. Some contracts may fall under provisions of Florida law which
require a three day "cooling off period." A clause advising the consumer of his
or her rights and responsibilities under this statute must be place
conspicuously in the contract.
Economics And Financing
Electric-resistance water heating represents about 25 percent of the average
electric bill in Florida. A solar water heater usually will provide about 75-90
percent of the household's hot water requirements on an annual basis. Therefore,
a solar system owner can achieve an overall 20 percent annual energy saving.
The cost of a solar system varies greatly, depending upon the materials of
the various components and services offered by the seller. Current average price
for an installed, active system ranges between $2,000 and $3,500. Specially
designed low-cost systems also are now available which provide about 40-50
percent of the household's hot water requirements for an installed cost of less
than $1,000. Compared with the cost of a conventional (electric or gas) water
heater, a solar system has a higher initial cost. However, to make an accurate
economic comparison, the cost of operating a conventional heater and renewable
energy financial incentives also must be considered.
Consider the following example: If the average installed system cost
is $2,500 and the electric utility offers a $400 rebate, the net system cost is
$2,100.
A family of four consumes, on the average, a total of 3600 kilowatt hours per
year to heat water electrically. A solar water heater can save 75 to 90 percent
of this electric consumption or approximately 3200 kilowatt hours per year. At
an average of 9 cents per kilowatt hour, this is an annual savings of $288.
Additional benefits to consider are that the savings are in after tax dollars;
you're using an environmentally clean source of power to heat water; and you've
made a real property investment in your home which will appreciate over time.
A "simple payback" analysis [$2,100 net investment) /$288 (annual savings)]
shows a payback of 7.29 years of 13.7% tax free return on your investment.
Considering that the average system last over 20 years, the savings over the
remaining life of the system (12.71 years) are additional tax free dollars in
your pocket.
Once the feasibility of a solar system and its cost/benefit aspects have been
investigated, you may need to consider financing. Financing is available through
commercial banks, savings and loan associations, credit unions and some system
dealers.
It is important that you take the following three steps to ensure the fairest
financing terms your credit merits:
1. Make sure the interest rate quoted to you conforms with federal
truth-in-lending statutes, which require the lender to disclose to the
borrower the annual percentage rate charged in the loan. This percentage
includes the interest rate, discount points and other charges collected by the
lender. 2. If the rate does not equal or better the equivalent FHA maximum
rate, find out why. 3. Negotiate the best possible rate and check other
lending institutions for a better deal in terms of interest rate, down payment
and length of loan. The ceiling on FHA-insured mortgages has been increased
by 20 percent to accommodate solar installations. This means that a buyer can
borrow funds in excess of the purchase price of the residence to help cover the
cost of a solar system. In order to qualify for an FHA mortgage the buyer must
have:
-A satisfactory credit record. -The cash needed at the closing of the
mortgage. -Enough steady income to make the monthly mortgage payments
without difficulty. FHA Title I home improvement loans for the retrofit of
existing residences are available from qualified lenders. Basically,
requirements are the same as the mortgage requirements with one exception--the
borrower must own the property or have a long-term lease on it. The loan can
cover architectural and engineering costs, building permit fees, materials and
installation. Application for the loan is made directly to any FHA-approved
lender, who determines the borrower's eligibility and processes the loan.
The Veterans Administration strongly supports energy conservation and will
guarantee loans to purchase, construct, refinance, repair or improve homes with
solar energy systems. Eligible veterans can obtain loans for the full value of a
solar system.
Operating And Maintenance
It is essential that you understand the operation and maintenance
requirements of your system. This will prevent minor problems from becoming
major ones or avoid common system malfunctions altogether. The best route to
this understanding is through careful review of the operating and maintenance
instructions manual provided by the seller.
While each system is different--and consequently operating and maintenance
instructions differ--there are certain basics that should be included in every
manual. FSEC has made inclusion of these basics mandatory under the solar
standards program. Under law, a manual including the following information must
be provided with every solar water and pool heating system:
1. Seller's name, address and system model number; 2. Explanation to
the buyer of the requirements for installation, operation and maintenance;
3. Procedures for start-up, shut-down, collector draining and any special
emergency procedures and safety precautions; 4. Description of major
components; 5. System diagram; 6. Parts list and the name and address
of a company offering service on the system. In addition, vendors must
provide a freeze protection instruction label. This label must be displayed in a
conspicuous location--usually affixed to the storage tank.
As with any major appliance, even the finest system may malfunction from time
to time. You may be able to solve simple problems yourself with relative ease,
using the troubleshooting checklist developed by FSEC in diagnosing system
malfunctions. However, be sure you are familiar with recommended procedures
before attempting a repair. Note also that unauthorized repairs may void the
warranties on the system or components. When in doubt, contact the responsible
firm listed on the warranty, which may be the installer, distributor or
manufacturer. If the system or the faulty component is no longer under warranty,
ask the installer about proper procedures to remedy the problem. If for some
reason the installer cannot be contacted, try the manufacturer.
Consumer Complaints
Local agencies, such as a consumer protection office or a Better Business
Bureau, may be able to investigate complaints and problems that have not been
resolved by other methods.
The division of Consumer Services in Tallahassee maintains a toll-free number
(1-800-342-2176) as well as several district offices to assist in complaint
resolution. The Attorney General's Office and local state attorney offices
receive and investigate complaints regarding unfair or deceptive business
practices.
The Department of Professional Regulation maintains a toll-free number for
consumer complaints (1-800-342-7940) and another to report unlicensed activity
or verify a contractor's license (1-800-851-1204). That office has jurisdiction
over licensed contractors and may intervene where a violation of the state's
construction contracting laws may exist. If your contractor is not licensed, you
also may check with the enforcement arm of your building department or the state
attorney's office. Installation of a solar system by an unlicensed contractor
(unless it is the homeowner) is a violation of state and local law.
The Department of Banking and Finance also may have jurisdiction over your
problem if the system was financed. This may be especially important if the
company which sold or manufactured your system is no longer in business. The
financing entity may be liable for repairs to you system in certain case. For
more information, contact the Department of Banking and Finance (904/487-2583).
|